Upper West Asides 03 Oct 2010 03:30 pm
Upper West Asides, 10/2/10 - Museum of Natural History
The Museum of Natural History. Everyone’s been there on school trips as a kid, but in Lisa’s humble opinion at least, this museum is far more suited for adults who are kids at heart than for actual children. For one thing, there’s authentic science on display, which you have to stop and read if you want to really understand what it is and why it’s important. Flashy displays and clickable screens soften up the difficulty somewhat, but the text is still geared for the adult beginner or possibly the child expert. Furthermore, there are far too many breakable and fragile objects around that people insist on touching and climbing on - looking at you two, Couple-Squeezed-Into-The-Giant-Clam. This museum is a place you want in your neighborhood, and Lisa loves living near it. So we spent almost five hours there on Saturday and left pretty close to closing time.
Overall Experience
Of all the times we’ve been to this museum, separately and together, this was the most we’ve gotten out of it. This may be because we arrived in the morning, saw the IMAX feature first, then timed the rest of our viewing so that we spaced out exhibits, gift shop perusing, and a coffee-and-cookie break. We entered through the Planetarium, which was far less crowded than the main entrance would have been, and since Lisa is a member, we were able to get tickets for both of us at a reduced rate (the lady at the desk gave Michael a “corporate rate” which was very nice of her, and unrequested by us).
We walked through the Planetarium, which is soon celebrating its 10th anniversary and has needed an update to reflect current planetary science for approximately the past 5 of those years. The text about the Moon, for example, states that it has no water, which is now known to exist in ice form near its South Pole. Many of the displays are now computerized so that they can provide “science bulletins”, which we looked at until it was time to head to the LeFrak IMAX theater for a lefraking interesting feature about the Hubble Space Telescope, narrated by non-scientist (even onscreen) Leonardo DiCaprio. We think perhaps they should recruit Patrick Stewart for their next narration, as he has the space cred as well as the gravitas in his voice to actually pull this off, unlike Whoopi Goldberg’s silly narration overlaying an otherwise exemplary space show.
While in the Planetarium we also stopped to fool around with one of the many video message kiosks scattered throughout the museum exhibits:
We enjoyed this so much, we made two more - one in the dinosaur hall and the other in the Hall of Biodiversity.
Our other main highlight was the “Race to the End of the Earth” walk-through exhibit, which depicted the struggle of two teams — British and Norwegian — to ‘discover’ the south pole. Only one of them made it back (guess who).
Michael: I’ve been to the AMNH more times than a TI-85 could count. About half of those visits happened during childhood, so whenever I go back, it’s like I’m touring my own natural history. The space shows stick in my mind most of all, and although the special effects have improved quite a bit since the early-mid 80s, the intellectual quotient has eroded. Instead of visiting astrophysicists presenting the space shows, we now have celebrity recordings. The shows are shorter, the syllables are fewer, but the cosmos is prettier. The “Race to the End of the Earth” expedition was a powerful new addition, showing us the folly of human pride. I’ve learned that if I ever decide to go the south pole, I shouldn’t bring ponies, make six-course meals from my rations, or refuse to join forces with my “competitors.” The Hall of Meteorites and the Hall of Minterals were fun in an imagination-stoking way. I couldn’t stop imagining shapes on the minerals’ surface and personifying the various nooks and crannies. Still disappointed that there’s no “kryptonite”, though, especially since there’s a real element named krypton.
Lisa: I often enjoy the special exhibitions at AMNH but almost always find things to criticize - and “Race to the End of the Earth” is no exception. This exhibition probably would play better as a clickable website than as a walk-through experience. Some interactivity was introduced via a map with sliding panels (”What animals did they see?” Slide the panel - “They saw penguins and seals.” I’m paraphrasing, but that’s the general flavor), cards picked up at the beginning of the exhibit that identified the viewer with one of six profiled expedition members and gave you a scavenger hunt item to locate, i.e. Roald Amundsen’s binoculars, and the occasional iPad-on-a-kiosk that featured an audiobook experience. The information was interesting, the story communicated as well as could be given the setup, the design sort of a retro turn-of-the-century-newspaper-headlines feel, but - is it too much of a pun to say it left me a bit cold? Yup, thought so… Gift shop with its plethora of penguins was fun, though.
I could go on and on about how to make the exhibition more child-friendly, or more exhibit-like in general, but I’ll be brief — more things to do, fewer things to read. Too many people crowding around a display waiting for a turn to flip electronic pages does not a fun museum visit make. I thought the Silk Road exhibit had a great balance of visuals, things to try out, and the overarching organizational tool of getting stamps in a passport worked well. Then again, the Silk Road was about a meeting of cultures and tradespeople, not a group of guys freezing their fingers off and shooting their ponies for food. Seriously, it’s not a happy ending. This is the kind of story I avoided before and during my own Antarctica trip for fear of getting thoroughly freaked out (not that I was anywhere near the South Pole, but people have died doing far less dangerous things…)
For me the highlight was finding hidden treasures in various exhibit halls - the ancient turtle ancestors in the dinosaur wing, Ken Miller in the Hall of Human Origins, bubbly-shaped crystal pieces in the Hall of Minerals, the photos from the Inca Trail outside the IMAX theater (I loved Peru and they have some great shots of some cool places I was, and wasn’t), and the subzero temperatures in the Hall of Meteorites that totally should have been reversed with the temperature settings in the Race to the Ends of the Earth. And the video kiosks! Did I mention those? They’re a lot of fun.
Score: 8.5 of 10 (Michael: 8, Lisa: 9)